The National Assembly Standing Committee on IT and Telecom, chaired by Aminul Haque, once again postponed the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill 2024 during its latest meeting. The bill, which aims to unify and digitalize Pakistan’s systems, was a key agenda item, but members called for more time to discuss and refine its provisions.
During the meeting, committee members raised concerns about the lack of a clear roadmap for the bill. Sharmila Faruqi criticized the Ministry for failing to provide clarity, urging it to present a comprehensive plan.
Similarly, Omer Ayub questioned the urgency of the Digital Nation Plan, suggesting that experts be involved and more time be allocated for discussions. He also emphasized the need for transparency and consultation with stakeholders, while criticizing the creation of a new bureaucracy under the proposed plan.
Shaza Fatima, Minister of State for IT, briefed the committee on the bill, emphasizing its importance for Pakistan’s digital future. She clarified that the bill was drafted locally and not copied from elsewhere. Fatima warned that delays in digitalization could push Pakistan into the “stone age,” stressing that technology waits for no one. She highlighted that the bill would empower citizens by enabling digital access to services such as ID cards, passports, and business registration.
Fatima also noted that the bill was developed in consultation with international and local experts, including the World Bank, Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and the Asian Development Bank. She acknowledged that digitalization is a costly endeavor, citing examples of countries like China and India, which took decades to achieve their digital transformation. She added that the government is committed to supporting the IT industry, ensuring uninterrupted internet access, and working on fiberization and spectrum policies.
Concerns Over Process and Representation
Other committee members expressed reservations about the bill’s introduction and structure. Arbab Alam criticized the sudden presentation of the bill, stating that the committee was not informed earlier. He also raised concerns about the lack of private members in the proposed 17-member commission. Zulfiqar Bhatti accused the government of rushing the bill, likening it to the way the country is being run. He suggested that the bill should address common issues such as internet speed and VPN access.
Pauline questioned whether the federal government had the authority to legislate on IT, as it is a provincial subject, and stressed the need for consultation with all stakeholders.
Support for the Bill
Despite the criticism, some members supported the bill. Romina Khurshid Alam called it a necessity of the time and urged the committee to pass it while allowing for further improvements. Fatima reiterated that the bill aims to empower citizens and transfer power from the state to the people.
Postponement for Further Consultation
Ultimately, the committee decided to postpone the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill 2024 for further consultation. The chairman invited members to submit their suggestions to refine the bill before it is presented again.
The World Bank remains a key partner in the program, while the Asian Development Bank is conducting a major study on Pakistan’s digitalization.
